- In Winter in my Room (1670)
- I reckon—when I count it all
- I saw no Way—The Heavens were stitched (378)
- I Started Early - Took my Dog
- I stepped from plank to plank
- I taste a liquor never brewed
- I taste a liquor never brewed (214)
- It Dropped So Low -- In My Regard
- I tend my flowers for thee (339)
- It feels a shame to be Alive (444)
- I think I was enchanted (593)
- It's all I have to bring today (26)
- It sifts from Leaden Sieves - (311)
- It was not Death, for I stood up (510)
- I was the slightest in the House
- I would not paint—a picture (505)
- I Years Had Been From Home
- Jesus! thy Crucifix
- Letter 233 (about 1861 - Franklin: Summer 1861) Master [unknown]
- Letter 260 (15 April 1862) T. W. Higginson ("Tell me what is true?")